Monday, January 30, 2023
ISSN 2765-8767
  • Survey
  • Podcast
  • Write for Us
Daily Remedy
  • Home
  • Articles
  • Podcasts
    A conversation with Dr. Selwyn O. Rogers, trauma surgeon and gun policy expert

    A conversation with Dr. Selwyn O. Rogers, trauma surgeon and gun policy expert

    November 25, 2022
    A conversation with Dr. Kyle Fischer, policy director for the Health Alliance for Violence Intervention

    A conversation with Dr. Kyle Fischer, policy director for the Health Alliance for Violence Intervention

    November 25, 2022
    A conversation with Dr. Edwin Leap, physician writer and emergency medicine physician

    A conversation with Dr. Edwin Leap, writer and emergency medicine physician

    November 8, 2022
    A conversation with Mr. Omar M Khateeb, innovator in medical device sales

    A conversation with Mr. Omar M Khateeb, innovator in medical device sales

    October 31, 2022
    A conversation with Miss Smriti Kirubanandan, passionate healthcare strategist

    A conversation with Miss Smriti Kirubanandan, passionate healthcare strategist

    October 23, 2022
    A conversation with Mr. Michael Johnson, legal expert in physician contracts

    A conversation with Mr. Michael Johnson, legal expert in physician contracts

    October 23, 2022
  • Surveys

    Surveys

    Does inflation affect how you use your deductible?

    Does inflation affect how you use your deductible?

    by Jay K Joshi
    December 12, 2022

    Survey Resutls

    How strongly do you believe that you can tell when your provider does not trust you?

    How strongly do you believe that you can tell when your provider does not trust you?

    October 16, 2022
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Support Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Articles
  • Podcasts
    A conversation with Dr. Selwyn O. Rogers, trauma surgeon and gun policy expert

    A conversation with Dr. Selwyn O. Rogers, trauma surgeon and gun policy expert

    November 25, 2022
    A conversation with Dr. Kyle Fischer, policy director for the Health Alliance for Violence Intervention

    A conversation with Dr. Kyle Fischer, policy director for the Health Alliance for Violence Intervention

    November 25, 2022
    A conversation with Dr. Edwin Leap, physician writer and emergency medicine physician

    A conversation with Dr. Edwin Leap, writer and emergency medicine physician

    November 8, 2022
    A conversation with Mr. Omar M Khateeb, innovator in medical device sales

    A conversation with Mr. Omar M Khateeb, innovator in medical device sales

    October 31, 2022
    A conversation with Miss Smriti Kirubanandan, passionate healthcare strategist

    A conversation with Miss Smriti Kirubanandan, passionate healthcare strategist

    October 23, 2022
    A conversation with Mr. Michael Johnson, legal expert in physician contracts

    A conversation with Mr. Michael Johnson, legal expert in physician contracts

    October 23, 2022
  • Surveys

    Surveys

    Does inflation affect how you use your deductible?

    Does inflation affect how you use your deductible?

    by Jay K Joshi
    December 12, 2022

    Survey Resutls

    How strongly do you believe that you can tell when your provider does not trust you?

    How strongly do you believe that you can tell when your provider does not trust you?

    October 16, 2022
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Support Us
No Result
View All Result
Daily Remedy
No Result
View All Result
Home Uncertainty & Complexity

Vaccine Mandates Strike at the Heart of Patient Autonomy

Jay K Joshi by Jay K Joshi
December 13, 2021
in Uncertainty & Complexity
0
Vaccine Mandates Strike at Heart of Patient Autonomy 2021.12.14

We believe vaccine mandates are important. But we also believe fighting for patient autonomy is important. So we compromise our logic.

We acknowledge that vaccines are beneficial, but we decry mandates. We acknowledge the value of science in healthcare, but we remain cautious.

When we try to articulate our hesitancy, we often say what we do not mean. We wax poetic about liberty and position it against science. We pretend as though vaccines are harmful, yet take vaccines willingly throughout our early life and elementary schooling.

In reality, our subconscious is fighting a war our conscious awareness has yet to fully grasp. We cannot yet articulate what we really think. So we posture and grandstand towards more familiar arguments.

This discrepancy is nothing new. In fact it seems to be the standard for public discourse in healthcare. We discuss abortion in terms of fetal viability yet reduce the issue into a matter of weeks of pregnancy. We discuss the need for harm reduction in treating patients with substance use dependency yet continue to stigmatize those afflicted.

We cannot help ourselves. We reduce the complex into the simple. And in healthcare, this means we reduce complex medical issues into simplified narratives. But in reducing something complex into something simple we often misunderstand the core issue at hand.

When we discuss vaccine mandates, we simplify it into a matter of individual liberties. But the issue is more visceral than liberties or rights and more complex than basic freedoms. The issue is the principle of patient autonomy.

Autonomy is independent of freedom. It is not defined by any one right or through written law. It is in the decisions we make, the subtle patterns of habit that define the essence of who we are. We value healthcare, but our implicit behaviors around healthy living balance what we know we should do against our personal preferences and tendencies.

Two patients diagnosed with diabetes may choose different courses of treatment. One may incorporate diet and exercise in an effort to stave off the need for medications. The other may maintain the same lifestyle yet adhere steadfastly to diabetic medications. And both may end up with equivalent blood sugar levels.

So who can say what the preferred course of action is? Both are compliant and both address their clinical condition through established treatment regimen. This is patient autonomy, the ability to choose how to manage one’s health. It is flexibility in the face of established protocol. It is the option to choose when the options are limited.

This is as good a definition as any of patient autonomy.

People feel threatened by vaccine mandates because they feel the mandates encroach onto patient autonomy. Yet the issue is articulated as a battle between individual liberties and trust in science. This is nothing more than simplifying a complex healthcare issue of patient autonomy into an easily digestible narrative.

The vaccines are not about trust. Most people implicitly trust science, even those who claim to be vaccine hesitant. The issue is not about trust or even science, but of a visceral sense of control.  We do not mind being told to take certain medications and vaccines as long as we feel that we are in control of the decision-making.

But the moment our sense of autonomy is questioned, we retaliate. This is the root of the anti-science rhetoric we hear of these days. In 1905 the Supreme Court ruled vaccine mandates were constitutional. Now we have lower court federal judges and Senate legislators readily shooting down vaccine mandates.

This reversal has nothing to do with former President Trump or some nascent Populist sentiment. It has everything to do with patient autonomy. And it comes from the technological and economic advancements of healthcare creating a visceral sense of encroachment onto patient autonomy.

Before healthcare was a cottage industry, relegated to the town doctor. Now healthcare is an economic juggernaut, absorbing nearly a third of the country’s GDP and nearly all the federal research dollars.

So with every app, email, and digitization comes an ever growing sense of technological control over patient decision-making.

It is time we confront the issue of autonomy head on. Look beyond the contrived arguments of liberty and trust, and see the issue for what it truly is – a growing, visceral fear of healthcare technology overtaking individual patient autonomy.

ShareTweet
Jay K Joshi

Jay K Joshi

Dr. Jay K Joshi serves as the editor-in-chief of Daily Remedy. He is a serial entrepreneur and sought after thought-leader for matters related to healthcare innovation and medical jurisprudence. He has published articles on a variety of healthcare topics in both peer-reviewed journals and trade publications. His legal writings include amicus curiae briefs prepared for prominent federal healthcare cases.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Videos

YouTube Video VVUxUDVQenU5RTFjUVFKNDY2ZlBmdFB3LmdVUm55WVpqRmNn This is a video about Elemental/Essential Frameworks of Healthcare Law

00:00 Elemental/Essential Frameworks of Healthcare Law
Load More... Subscribe

Expert vs. Lay Testimony

Visuals

NADAC (National Average Drug Acquisition Cost)

NADAC (National Average Drug Acquisition Cost)

by Jay K Joshi
January 29, 2023
0

We list the acquisition price of drugs that are covered under the Medicaid Drug Rebate Program - effectively, how much does the government pay for common drugs utilized by patients on Medicaid. Drugs listed are from A-CH.  

Read more

Twitter Updates

Tweets by DailyRemedy1

Newsletter

Start your Daily Remedy journey

Cultivate your knowledge of current healthcare events and ensure you receive the most accurate, insightful healthcare news and editorials.

*we hate spam as much as you do

Popular

  • Letter to the Alabama Board of Medical Examiners

    Letter to the Alabama Board of Medical Examiners

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Prosecuting Doctors as Drug Dealers

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Malicious Prosecution and Fabrication of Evidence

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Why Our Prescribing were for Patients’ Best Interests

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • My Respect for the Law

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Daily Remedy

Daily Remedy offers the best in healthcare information and healthcare editorial content. We take pride in consistently delivering only the highest quality of insight and analysis to ensure our audience is well-informed about current healthcare topics - beyond the traditional headlines.

Daily Remedy website services, content, and products are for informational purposes only. We do not provide medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. All rights reserved.

Important Links

  • Support Us
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

Newsletter

Start your Daily Remedy journey

Cultivate your knowledge of current healthcare events and ensure you receive the most accurate, insightful healthcare news and editorials.

*we hate spam as much as you do

  • Survey
  • Podcast
  • About Us
  • Contact us

© 2023 Daily Remedy

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Articles
    • Contrarian
    • Financial Markets
    • Innovations & Investing
    • Perspectives
    • Politics & Law
    • Trends
    • Uncertainty & Complexity
  • Podcasts
  • Surveys
    • Survey Results
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Support Us

© 2023 Daily Remedy

Start your Daily Remedy journey

Cultivate your knowledge of current healthcare events and ensure you receive the most accurate, insightful healthcare news and editorials.

*we hate spam as much as you do