Tuesday, January 31, 2023
ISSN 2765-8767
  • Survey
  • Podcast
  • Write for Us
Daily Remedy
  • Home
  • Articles
  • Podcasts
    A conversation with Dr. Selwyn O. Rogers, trauma surgeon and gun policy expert

    A conversation with Dr. Selwyn O. Rogers, trauma surgeon and gun policy expert

    November 25, 2022
    A conversation with Dr. Kyle Fischer, policy director for the Health Alliance for Violence Intervention

    A conversation with Dr. Kyle Fischer, policy director for the Health Alliance for Violence Intervention

    November 25, 2022
    A conversation with Dr. Edwin Leap, physician writer and emergency medicine physician

    A conversation with Dr. Edwin Leap, writer and emergency medicine physician

    November 8, 2022
    A conversation with Mr. Omar M Khateeb, innovator in medical device sales

    A conversation with Mr. Omar M Khateeb, innovator in medical device sales

    October 31, 2022
    A conversation with Miss Smriti Kirubanandan, passionate healthcare strategist

    A conversation with Miss Smriti Kirubanandan, passionate healthcare strategist

    October 23, 2022
    A conversation with Mr. Michael Johnson, legal expert in physician contracts

    A conversation with Mr. Michael Johnson, legal expert in physician contracts

    October 23, 2022
  • Surveys

    Surveys

    Does inflation affect how you use your deductible?

    Does inflation affect how you use your deductible?

    by Jay K Joshi
    December 12, 2022

    Survey Resutls

    How strongly do you believe that you can tell when your provider does not trust you?

    How strongly do you believe that you can tell when your provider does not trust you?

    October 16, 2022
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Support Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Articles
  • Podcasts
    A conversation with Dr. Selwyn O. Rogers, trauma surgeon and gun policy expert

    A conversation with Dr. Selwyn O. Rogers, trauma surgeon and gun policy expert

    November 25, 2022
    A conversation with Dr. Kyle Fischer, policy director for the Health Alliance for Violence Intervention

    A conversation with Dr. Kyle Fischer, policy director for the Health Alliance for Violence Intervention

    November 25, 2022
    A conversation with Dr. Edwin Leap, physician writer and emergency medicine physician

    A conversation with Dr. Edwin Leap, writer and emergency medicine physician

    November 8, 2022
    A conversation with Mr. Omar M Khateeb, innovator in medical device sales

    A conversation with Mr. Omar M Khateeb, innovator in medical device sales

    October 31, 2022
    A conversation with Miss Smriti Kirubanandan, passionate healthcare strategist

    A conversation with Miss Smriti Kirubanandan, passionate healthcare strategist

    October 23, 2022
    A conversation with Mr. Michael Johnson, legal expert in physician contracts

    A conversation with Mr. Michael Johnson, legal expert in physician contracts

    October 23, 2022
  • Surveys

    Surveys

    Does inflation affect how you use your deductible?

    Does inflation affect how you use your deductible?

    by Jay K Joshi
    December 12, 2022

    Survey Resutls

    How strongly do you believe that you can tell when your provider does not trust you?

    How strongly do you believe that you can tell when your provider does not trust you?

    October 16, 2022
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Support Us
No Result
View All Result
Daily Remedy
No Result
View All Result
Home Contrarian

Medicine is a Duty, Not a Right

Jay K Joshi by Jay K Joshi
August 27, 2022
in Contrarian
0
Medicine is a Duty, Not a Right

When we think of rights in healthcare, we think of protecting the patient. In reality, we are placing the patient at odds with their medical care.

Rights are something to protect, implying that they are something to protect against. It is a subtle cognitive shift, but it matters when dealing with subtle clinical decisions. Consider the following patient scenario.

A sixty-five-year-old Hispanic female with diabetes has a non-healing wound in her right heel. She has tried improving her diet and adjusting her medications, even adding insulin injections. Nothing has worked. She is now opting for surgery to debride her wound. This can proceed in one of two ways.

In one scenario, we think of the patient safeguarding against all liabilities. She reviews the consent; she monitors for all possible adverse outcomes or risks. She ensures she is protected, that she knows of her rights.

In the other scenario, she takes a far less adversarial approach. She focuses on preparing herself for surgery: maintaining the appropriate level of physical activity, eating better, monitoring her blood sugar closely, and avoiding things that would worsen the wound.

Both scenarios play out the same, a successful debridement, but the perspectives of the patient differ. And likely, so will the long term post-operative outcomes. Looking at medicine as a series of rights to protect or restrict is in vogue right now, particularly with a conspicuous, litigious veneer covering the most polarizing health issues today.

But there is a better way to look at healthcare. Instead of thinking about patient rights, think about patient duties. Rights are what we have, what is owed; duties are what we should do, what we owe. One is passive; the other is active.

Healthcare, at its root, is a series of active decisions. The hypothetical patient above does not randomly become diabetic. She makes decisions that culminate in her diagnosis.

And we can view her decisions from the perspective of either rights or duties. In the former, the patient expects certain services, and demands certain outcomes and results to be met. In the latter, the patient considers her role in preparing for the surgery and recovering from it. In the second scenario, the patient is actively engaged in the process. She is in control.

We talk a big game about bodily autonomy: “my body, my choice”. But we talk little about bodily agency, the consequences that come with the responsibility of autonomy. We conveniently miss this correlation when we consider only patient rights.

But when we think of duty, a patient’s responsibility in the process of healthcare, the autonomy comes with agency, hand in hand.

The shift in thinking may be subtle, but the patient outcomes are not. In fact, clinical outcomes improve when we think of duty instead of rights.

While we can wax poetic about the reasons for this, the issue boils down to one thing: when we think of medicine in terms of rights, we think individually. When we think of medicine in terms of duty, we think of our obligation to others.

This matters because medicine is inherently a service. Yet, we look at it like a product, focusing only on the outcome. Service is ongoing, an outcome has finality. This misunderstanding lies at the heart of why we cannot think of rights in medicine.

As long as we apply such thinking to medicine, we will always be at odds with each other. My rights conflict with your rights. A physician’s right to make medical decisions conflicts with a patient’s rights to do as he or she pleases.

But when we think of duty, we become reconciliatory. The physician is obligated to the patient as much as the patient is obligated to the physician.

This is not just an exercise in idealized rhetoric. We have ways of implementing this thinking in medicine: adjust the incentives to be reconciliatory.

As it currently stands, medicine focuses on individual protections and liabilities. Instead, if we reward communication, active engagement between patients and physicians, then what was once a liability becomes an opportunity to discuss treatment options.

Like the hypothetical patient with the diabetic wound. If she only focuses on her individual right and the liability of others, then she will be less engaged. But if she considers her role in the surgery, then she will see herself as part of a system in service of her health – with a responsibility to those who are caring for her.

She will see it as a matter of duty.

ShareTweet
Jay K Joshi

Jay K Joshi

Dr. Jay K Joshi serves as the editor-in-chief of Daily Remedy. He is a serial entrepreneur and sought after thought-leader for matters related to healthcare innovation and medical jurisprudence. He has published articles on a variety of healthcare topics in both peer-reviewed journals and trade publications. His legal writings include amicus curiae briefs prepared for prominent federal healthcare cases.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Videos

YouTube Video VVUxUDVQenU5RTFjUVFKNDY2ZlBmdFB3LmdVUm55WVpqRmNn This is a video about Elemental/Essential Frameworks of Healthcare Law

00:00 Elemental/Essential Frameworks of Healthcare Law
Load More... Subscribe

Expert vs. Lay Testimony

Visuals

NADAC (National Average Drug Acquisition Cost)

NADAC (National Average Drug Acquisition Cost)

by Jay K Joshi
January 29, 2023
0

We list the acquisition price of drugs that are covered under the Medicaid Drug Rebate Program - effectively, how much does the government pay for common drugs utilized by patients on Medicaid. Drugs listed are from A-CH.  

Read more

Twitter Updates

Tweets by DailyRemedy1

Newsletter

Start your Daily Remedy journey

Cultivate your knowledge of current healthcare events and ensure you receive the most accurate, insightful healthcare news and editorials.

*we hate spam as much as you do

Popular

  • Letter to the Alabama Board of Medical Examiners

    Letter to the Alabama Board of Medical Examiners

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Malicious Prosecution and Fabrication of Evidence

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Prosecuting Doctors as Drug Dealers

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • My Respect for the Law

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Why Our Prescribing were for Patients’ Best Interests

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Daily Remedy

Daily Remedy offers the best in healthcare information and healthcare editorial content. We take pride in consistently delivering only the highest quality of insight and analysis to ensure our audience is well-informed about current healthcare topics - beyond the traditional headlines.

Daily Remedy website services, content, and products are for informational purposes only. We do not provide medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. All rights reserved.

Important Links

  • Support Us
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

Newsletter

Start your Daily Remedy journey

Cultivate your knowledge of current healthcare events and ensure you receive the most accurate, insightful healthcare news and editorials.

*we hate spam as much as you do

  • Survey
  • Podcast
  • About Us
  • Contact us

© 2023 Daily Remedy

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Articles
    • Contrarian
    • Financial Markets
    • Innovations & Investing
    • Perspectives
    • Politics & Law
    • Trends
    • Uncertainty & Complexity
  • Podcasts
  • Surveys
    • Survey Results
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Support Us

© 2023 Daily Remedy

Start your Daily Remedy journey

Cultivate your knowledge of current healthcare events and ensure you receive the most accurate, insightful healthcare news and editorials.

*we hate spam as much as you do