Friday, February 3, 2023
ISSN 2765-8767
  • Survey
  • Podcast
  • Write for Us
Daily Remedy
  • Home
  • Articles
  • Podcasts
    A conversation with Dr. Selwyn O. Rogers, trauma surgeon and gun policy expert

    A conversation with Dr. Selwyn O. Rogers, trauma surgeon and gun policy expert

    November 25, 2022
    A conversation with Dr. Kyle Fischer, policy director for the Health Alliance for Violence Intervention

    A conversation with Dr. Kyle Fischer, policy director for the Health Alliance for Violence Intervention

    November 25, 2022
    A conversation with Dr. Edwin Leap, physician writer and emergency medicine physician

    A conversation with Dr. Edwin Leap, writer and emergency medicine physician

    November 8, 2022
    A conversation with Mr. Omar M Khateeb, innovator in medical device sales

    A conversation with Mr. Omar M Khateeb, innovator in medical device sales

    October 31, 2022
    A conversation with Miss Smriti Kirubanandan, passionate healthcare strategist

    A conversation with Miss Smriti Kirubanandan, passionate healthcare strategist

    October 23, 2022
    A conversation with Mr. Michael Johnson, legal expert in physician contracts

    A conversation with Mr. Michael Johnson, legal expert in physician contracts

    October 23, 2022
  • Surveys

    Surveys

    Does inflation affect how you use your deductible?

    Does inflation affect how you use your deductible?

    by Jay K Joshi
    December 12, 2022

    Survey Resutls

    How strongly do you believe that you can tell when your provider does not trust you?

    How strongly do you believe that you can tell when your provider does not trust you?

    October 16, 2022
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Support Us
  • Purchase DME
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Articles
  • Podcasts
    A conversation with Dr. Selwyn O. Rogers, trauma surgeon and gun policy expert

    A conversation with Dr. Selwyn O. Rogers, trauma surgeon and gun policy expert

    November 25, 2022
    A conversation with Dr. Kyle Fischer, policy director for the Health Alliance for Violence Intervention

    A conversation with Dr. Kyle Fischer, policy director for the Health Alliance for Violence Intervention

    November 25, 2022
    A conversation with Dr. Edwin Leap, physician writer and emergency medicine physician

    A conversation with Dr. Edwin Leap, writer and emergency medicine physician

    November 8, 2022
    A conversation with Mr. Omar M Khateeb, innovator in medical device sales

    A conversation with Mr. Omar M Khateeb, innovator in medical device sales

    October 31, 2022
    A conversation with Miss Smriti Kirubanandan, passionate healthcare strategist

    A conversation with Miss Smriti Kirubanandan, passionate healthcare strategist

    October 23, 2022
    A conversation with Mr. Michael Johnson, legal expert in physician contracts

    A conversation with Mr. Michael Johnson, legal expert in physician contracts

    October 23, 2022
  • Surveys

    Surveys

    Does inflation affect how you use your deductible?

    Does inflation affect how you use your deductible?

    by Jay K Joshi
    December 12, 2022

    Survey Resutls

    How strongly do you believe that you can tell when your provider does not trust you?

    How strongly do you believe that you can tell when your provider does not trust you?

    October 16, 2022
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Support Us
  • Purchase DME
No Result
View All Result
Daily Remedy
No Result
View All Result
Home Politics & Law

When Law Targets Physicians

Jay K Joshi by Jay K Joshi
September 6, 2022
in Politics & Law
0
When Law Targets Physicians

Without law, there can be no crime; without crime, there can be no punishment.

The phrase is a bastardization of the legal concept, Nullum crimen sine lege, which states you cannot be punished for doing something not prohibited by law. But it is the reality facing many physicians today.

“We are investigating this situation and are waiting for the relevant documents to prove if the abortion and/or the abuse were reported, as Dr. Caitlin Bernard had requirements to do both under Indiana law. The failure to do so constitutes a crime in Indiana, and her behavior could also affect her licensure. Additionally, if a HIPAA violation did occur, that may affect next steps as well. I will not relent in the pursuit of the truth.”

These were the words Indiana Attorney General Todd Rokita issued in a statement following news an abortion was performed by Dr. Caitlin Bernard on a ten year old rape victim in the state of Indiana. The story garnered headlines for all the wrong reasons.

First anti-abortion activists and media outlets decried the story as a hoax. A few days later, it was verified. Then the same folks who called it a hoax went after the physician who performed the procedure and called her – in no uncertain terms – a criminal. To the physician’s credit, she fought back. Dr. Bernard lawyered up and sent a cease-and-desist letter to Indiana Attorney General Todd Rokita.

“Your false and defamatory statements to Fox News on July 13, 2022, cast Dr. Bernard in a false light and allege misconduct in her profession…”

In response, a spokesperson for Rokita’s office wrote in an email that the cease-and-desist letter will be reviewed when it arrives but denies any wrongdoing.

“No false or misleading statements have been made.”

The story will probably fizzle out and it is unlikely Indiana’s Office of Attorney General will pursue any investigation or take any legal action. Dr. Bernard followed all state guidelines and reporting practices as mandated. She committed no crime. She did not even violate any administrative protocol. And though she appears to be preparing a defamation lawsuit, it is unlikely to go anywhere either.

But that is not the point. What is concerning is that it became a story at all. Yes, rape is terrible. Yes, Americans are divided on the morality of abortions. But what Rokita did in targeting Dr. Bernard is the worst sin by far in this entire debacle.

He effectively created a precedent to target physicians by using the pretense of law to inflict punishment on physicians practicing clinical medicine. Notice he never challenged the procedure itself. He never questioned whether the abortion was legal. He questioned whether Dr. Bernard complied with the state’s reporting standards or violated patient privacy laws, all of which are tangential to the actual care itself.

Such administrative measures are in place to ensure good clinical practices. They should uphold a standard of care, not dictate the course of clinical care. But when Rokita targeted Dr. Bernard, he turned those measures into legal weapons, effectively converting them into punitive tactics that can be used against physicians.

Make no mistake; this will affect abortion providers in Indiana and across the country. Politically ambitious lawmakers and prosecutors will seize the opportunity to use legal oversight as a proxy for criminality to target physicians, and garner career enhancing convictions in the process. It is no secret the risk of legal liability drives clinical behavior. Just ask any physician who has faced a malpractice lawsuit.

It changes the way physicians think and the way they provide care. But not in ways that are immediately obvious. The real effect is felt among other physicians and throughout the medical community.

Think of it like herd behavior. When one physician is disgraced and humiliated, the shame reverberates across all of medicine. Nobody wants to be the next physician who gets shamed, so nobody acts in a way that remotely resembles the behavior of the physician being castigated.

We have few legal remedies in medicine that equate fair legal liability for medical errors or physician misconduct. Instead, the law has resorted to scorched earth tactics to destroy physicians. Such tactics punish other physicians by instilling a palpable sense of dread that seeps into every clinical decision made.

Most physicians respond by either avoiding any similar circumstance. But of late, some have mustered a semblance of legal fortitude, as with Dr. Bernard. But few carry her gumption. Most would rather avoid any legal liability or any unwelcomed limelight. And who can blame them? Physicians never asked to be pawns in a political game of power.

Yet life has a funny way of imposing itself. These legal impositions into medicine show no signs of abating and might actually get worse. It will adversely affect the profession of medicine and direct clinical care in ways we have yet to grasp. Ultimately, patients will be the ones who suffer when law targets physicians.

ShareTweet
Jay K Joshi

Jay K Joshi

Dr. Jay K Joshi serves as the editor-in-chief of Daily Remedy. He is a serial entrepreneur and sought after thought-leader for matters related to healthcare innovation and medical jurisprudence. He has published articles on a variety of healthcare topics in both peer-reviewed journals and trade publications. His legal writings include amicus curiae briefs prepared for prominent federal healthcare cases.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Videos

YouTube Video VVUxUDVQenU5RTFjUVFKNDY2ZlBmdFB3LmdVUm55WVpqRmNn This is a video about Elemental/Essential Frameworks of Healthcare Law

00:00 Elemental/Essential Frameworks of Healthcare Law
Load More... Subscribe

Expert vs. Lay Testimony

Visuals

NADAC (National Average Drug Acquisition Cost)

NADAC (National Average Drug Acquisition Cost)

by Jay K Joshi
January 29, 2023
0

We list the acquisition price of drugs that are covered under the Medicaid Drug Rebate Program - effectively, how much does the government pay for common drugs utilized by patients on Medicaid. Drugs listed are from A-CH.  

Read more

Twitter Updates

Tweets by DailyRemedy1

Newsletter

Start your Daily Remedy journey

Cultivate your knowledge of current healthcare events and ensure you receive the most accurate, insightful healthcare news and editorials.

*we hate spam as much as you do

Popular

  • Malicious Prosecution and Fabrication of Evidence

    Malicious Prosecution and Fabrication of Evidence

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • 2022 Letter to the American Medical Association

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • 2023 Letter to the American Medical Association

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Letter to the Alabama Board of Medical Examiners

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Prosecuting Doctors as Drug Dealers

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Daily Remedy

Daily Remedy offers the best in healthcare information and healthcare editorial content. We take pride in consistently delivering only the highest quality of insight and analysis to ensure our audience is well-informed about current healthcare topics - beyond the traditional headlines.

Daily Remedy website services, content, and products are for informational purposes only. We do not provide medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. All rights reserved.

Important Links

  • Support Us
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

Newsletter

Start your Daily Remedy journey

Cultivate your knowledge of current healthcare events and ensure you receive the most accurate, insightful healthcare news and editorials.

*we hate spam as much as you do

  • Survey
  • Podcast
  • About Us
  • Contact us

© 2023 Daily Remedy

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Articles
    • Contrarian
    • Financial Markets
    • Innovations & Investing
    • Perspectives
    • Politics & Law
    • Trends
    • Uncertainty & Complexity
  • Podcasts
  • Surveys
    • Survey Results
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Support Us

© 2023 Daily Remedy

Start your Daily Remedy journey

Cultivate your knowledge of current healthcare events and ensure you receive the most accurate, insightful healthcare news and editorials.

*we hate spam as much as you do