Thursday, June 19, 2025
ISSN 2765-8767
  • Survey
  • Podcast
  • Write for Us
  • My Account
  • Log In
Daily Remedy
  • Home
  • Articles
  • Podcasts
    Navigating the Medical Licensing Maze

    The Fight Against Healthcare Fraud: Dr. Rafai’s Story

    April 8, 2025
    Navigating the Medical Licensing Maze

    Navigating the Medical Licensing Maze

    April 4, 2025
    The Alarming Truth About Health Insurance Denials

    The Alarming Truth About Health Insurance Denials

    February 3, 2025
    Telehealth in Turmoil

    The Importance of NIH Grants

    January 31, 2025
    The New Era of Patient Empowerment

    The New Era of Patient Empowerment

    January 29, 2025
    Physicians: Write Thy Briefs

    Physicians: Write thy amicus briefs!

    January 26, 2025
  • Surveys

    Surveys

    Perception vs. Comprehension: Public Understanding of the 2025 MAHA Report

    Perception vs. Comprehension: Public Understanding of the 2025 MAHA Report

    June 4, 2025
    Understanding Public Perception and Awareness of Medicare Advantage and Payment Change

    Understanding Public Perception and Awareness of Medicare Advantage and Payment Change

    April 4, 2025

    Survey Results

    Do you believe national polls on health issues are accurate

    National health polls: trust in healthcare system accuracy?

    May 8, 2024
    Which health policy issues matter the most to Republican voters in the primaries?

    Which health policy issues matter the most to Republican voters in the primaries?

    May 14, 2024
    How strongly do you believe that you can tell when your provider does not trust you?

    How strongly do you believe that you can tell when your provider does not trust you?

    May 7, 2024
  • Courses
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Support Us
  • Official Learner
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Articles
  • Podcasts
    Navigating the Medical Licensing Maze

    The Fight Against Healthcare Fraud: Dr. Rafai’s Story

    April 8, 2025
    Navigating the Medical Licensing Maze

    Navigating the Medical Licensing Maze

    April 4, 2025
    The Alarming Truth About Health Insurance Denials

    The Alarming Truth About Health Insurance Denials

    February 3, 2025
    Telehealth in Turmoil

    The Importance of NIH Grants

    January 31, 2025
    The New Era of Patient Empowerment

    The New Era of Patient Empowerment

    January 29, 2025
    Physicians: Write Thy Briefs

    Physicians: Write thy amicus briefs!

    January 26, 2025
  • Surveys

    Surveys

    Perception vs. Comprehension: Public Understanding of the 2025 MAHA Report

    Perception vs. Comprehension: Public Understanding of the 2025 MAHA Report

    June 4, 2025
    Understanding Public Perception and Awareness of Medicare Advantage and Payment Change

    Understanding Public Perception and Awareness of Medicare Advantage and Payment Change

    April 4, 2025

    Survey Results

    Do you believe national polls on health issues are accurate

    National health polls: trust in healthcare system accuracy?

    May 8, 2024
    Which health policy issues matter the most to Republican voters in the primaries?

    Which health policy issues matter the most to Republican voters in the primaries?

    May 14, 2024
    How strongly do you believe that you can tell when your provider does not trust you?

    How strongly do you believe that you can tell when your provider does not trust you?

    May 7, 2024
  • Courses
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Support Us
  • Official Learner
No Result
View All Result
Daily Remedy
No Result
View All Result
Home Politics & Law

Healthcare Laws are Oaths

In medicine, a law is never just a law

Daily Remedy by Daily Remedy
February 11, 2023
in Politics & Law
0
Healthcare Laws are Oaths

Muesse

The first healthcare laws were not laws as we understand them today, but oaths – the most famous being the Hippocratic Oath. Physicians taking the oath vow to uphold principles of good patient care, as a duty that affords them the right to practice clinical medicine.

For as much as we reference the oath today, we know little about Hippocrates himself. We rely heavily on his writings to understand his medical philosophies. We know he practiced medicine on the Greek island of Kos, an intellectual center of Hellenistic culture. He challenged many of his contemporary physicians, who advocated for rational and logical approaches to patient care. Hippocrates in contrast emphasized intuition and considered direct patient experience the most important factor in curing illness.

Interestingly, the oath itself was not even written by Hippocrates, but by his students after his death, ostensibly to formalize his philosophy, but in reality to distinguish physicians trained under his methods, in order to create a competitive advantage for his pupils – transforming a hallowed oath that balanced duty with rights into a series of phrases that restricted competition among schools of medicine.

This transformation continues to the present, as we take select phrases from medical oaths and paraphrase them into contrived interpretations.

This is exemplified in the phrase “Do no harm,” which ironically never appeared in the original oath. Though it appears in legal courts today, when lawyers decry the actions of healthcare providers who have purportedly violated their duties to their patients. But we cannot discern individual responsibilities through individual actions alone. The clinical context and the underlying medical condition define the importance of all the clinical actions and obligations.

As the physician-philosopher Maimonides said, “The greater the contradiction, the deeper the wisdom.” The deep wisdom contained within physician oaths describes the nature of rights in healthcare as a relationship between healthcare responsibilities or duties, and rights afforded, which may appear as contradictions, but merely serve two sides in a deep rooted balance.

The relationship, linked by the lines defined in the oaths, must be understood as a balance, to be experienced as much as learned, felt as much as deduced. It comes from principles of humanism, which serves as the roots of modern medicine and explains why we characterize health through our experiences.

The physicians who form the pantheon of medicine all emphasized an experience-based approach to healthcare. Hippocrates characterized medicine as an art to be practiced, and said that it consists not of treating a disease but of healing a person.

Famed Roman surgeon Galen began his medical career as a surgeon treating dying gladiators. Soon he became renowned for his experimental approach to medicine, eventually serving as the private physician to the Caesars. His career trajectory was emulated centuries later by Maimonides, who became the personal physician to Saladin, the legendary Muslim Crusader. Maimonides also took an experimental approach to medicine, but emphasized civic responsibility as well.

These traits would later inspire Canadian physician William Osler’s humanistic approach to medicine at the turn of the twentieth century. Dr. Osler, who is best known for turning John Hopkins Medical Center into a research juggernaut, also designed a clinical curriculum that became the model for modern medical education in the United States. He prioritized the clinic as much as the textbook, and believed direct patient contact is the bedrock of good medicine.

When we look at medicine through its humanistic origins, we better understand the balance between healthcare and law. Henry David Thoreau emphasized moral behavior in broad terms, more than any individual civic action, as a person’s civic duty to society. Thoreau’s views on civic duty stem from his perspective on individual rights, which he held sacred above all, including above government intervention. Thoreau encouraged individuals whose rights were compromised inappropriately to serve as a “counter-friction to a fundamental immorality.” He believed laws should be in balance with an individual’s fundamental rights, and that a law’s validity should be measured by its morality.

Healthcare rights are similarly defined through distinct qualities and manifest in different ways, but the fundamental concept of health pervades beyond any clinical distinction. If physicians do not believe they can give medical advice to a patient or perform a procedure for fear of backlash or litigation, then physicians lose the inclination to share advice or perform procedures, reverting to more defensive tendencies of self-protection that affects patient care.

They have violated their oath. It’s that simple and that complex. In healthcare, an action is never just an action, like a law is never just a law. Individual actions or decisions matter far less than the overall behavior and its intent. That’s why the first healthcare laws were oaths.

ShareTweet
Daily Remedy

Daily Remedy

Dr. Jay K Joshi serves as the editor-in-chief of Daily Remedy. He is a serial entrepreneur and sought after thought-leader for matters related to healthcare innovation and medical jurisprudence. He has published articles on a variety of healthcare topics in both peer-reviewed journals and trade publications. His legal writings include amicus curiae briefs prepared for prominent federal healthcare cases.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Videos

Summary

In this episode of the Daily Remedy Podcast, Dr. Joshi discusses the rapidly changing landscape of healthcare laws and trends, emphasizing the importance of understanding the distinction between statutory and case law. The conversation highlights the role of case law in shaping healthcare practices and encourages physicians to engage in legal advocacy by writing legal briefs to influence case law outcomes. The episode underscores the need for physicians to actively participate in the legal processes that govern their practice.

Takeaways

Healthcare trends are rapidly changing and confusing.
Understanding statutory and case law is crucial for physicians.
Case law can overturn existing statutory laws.
Physicians can influence healthcare law through legal briefs.
Writing legal briefs doesn't require extensive legal knowledge.
Narrative formats can be effective in legal briefs.
Physicians should express their perspectives in legal matters.
Engagement in legal advocacy is essential for physicians.
The interpretation of case law affects medical practice.
Physicians need to be part of the legal conversation.
Physicians: Write thy amicus briefs!
YouTube Video FFRYHFXhT4k
Subscribe

MD Angels Investor Pitch

Visuals

Official MAHA Report

Official MAHA Report

by Daily Remedy
May 31, 2025
0

Explore the official MAHA Report released by the White House in May 2025.

Read more

Twitter Updates

Tweets by DailyRemedy1

Newsletter

Start your Daily Remedy journey

Cultivate your knowledge of current healthcare events and ensure you receive the most accurate, insightful healthcare news and editorials.

*we hate spam as much as you do

Popular

  • The Double-Edged Hype: Rethinking the Weight-Loss Drug Boom

    The Double-Edged Hype: Rethinking the Weight-Loss Drug Boom

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Feathers and Forecasts: Why the Bird Flu Surge Demands America’s Attention Now

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • The Anxious Generation: Why Gen Z Is Leading the Mental Health Revolution

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • The Grey Market of Weight Loss: How Compounded GLP-1 Medications Continue Despite FDA Crackdowns

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • The First FBI Agent I Met

    3 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • 628 Followers

Daily Remedy

Daily Remedy offers the best in healthcare information and healthcare editorial content. We take pride in consistently delivering only the highest quality of insight and analysis to ensure our audience is well-informed about current healthcare topics - beyond the traditional headlines.

Daily Remedy website services, content, and products are for informational purposes only. We do not provide medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. All rights reserved.

Important Links

  • Support Us
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

Newsletter

Start your Daily Remedy journey

Cultivate your knowledge of current healthcare events and ensure you receive the most accurate, insightful healthcare news and editorials.

*we hate spam as much as you do

  • Survey
  • Podcast
  • About Us
  • Contact us

© 2025 Daily Remedy

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Articles
  • Podcasts
  • Surveys
  • Courses
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Support Us
  • Official Learner

© 2025 Daily Remedy

Start your Daily Remedy journey

Cultivate your knowledge of current healthcare events and ensure you receive the most accurate, insightful healthcare news and editorials.

*we hate spam as much as you do